The HABRI Foundation is calling for research proposals to investigate the health outcomes of pet ownership and/or animal-assisted activity or therapy, both for the people and the animals involved. To learn more, visit close

You are here: Home / Theses / The representation of dogs as family in contemporary American documentary film / About

The representation of dogs as family in contemporary American documentary film

By Jennifer Elizabeth Grace

View Link (HTM)

Licensed under

Category Theses

The American family dog is a social construct that blurs the ontological boundaries of nature/culture dualism and which contemporary American documentary filmmakers represent by employing alternate tropes of 'dog as human' and 'dog as animal.' In filmic and practical use, these tropes are in flux and are confusing. The position of the dog as a paradox of nature and culture and member of the contemporary inter-species family makes the decision to euthanize it ethically challenging. Non-fiction dog programming is more popular than ever and most shows employ the 'dog as human' trope. But few address at what point that trope breaks down and how to find the line between 'dog as human' and 'dog as animal' when making ethical decisions for dogs. I will prove this by describing movies like Why We Love Cats and Dogs (Ellen Goosenberg Kent 2009) that rely on removed experts to explain the how humans are similar to dogs and those like Shelter Dogs (Cynthia Wade 2003) that follow devastating moments of loss with cheery depictions of renewal. My thesis film Soul Dog instead dives into the deep emotional conflict that many of us face in a society where dogs have become surrogate for family. Using personal subjective storytelling techniques like that in Sherman's March (McElwee 1986) and quirky vox pop interviews similar to those in Gates of Heaven, (Morris 1978) I focus on the personal stories and popular wisdom that influence our actions.


Marcy Wilhelm-South

Purdue University

Date 2010
Pages 36
Department Media and Theater Arts
Degree Master of Fine Arts
Language English
University Montana State University
Cite this work

Researchers should cite this work as follows:

  1. Animal roles
  2. Dogs
  3. Family
  4. Films
  5. Mammals
  6. Media
  7. Pet ownership
  8. Pets and companion animals
  9. Pets as family members