You are here: Home / Journal Articles / The rationality of biofuel certification: a critical examination of EU biofuel policy / About

The rationality of biofuel certification: a critical examination of EU biofuel policy

By A. J. K. Pols

View Link (HTM)

Licensed under

Category Journal Articles

Certification for biofuels has been developed to ensure that biofuel production methods adhere to social and environmental sustainability standards. As such, requiring biofuel production to be certified has become part of EU policy through the 2009 renewable energy directive (RED), that aims to promote energy security, reduce emissions and promote rural development. According to the EU RED, in 2020 10% of our transport energy should come from renewable sources, most of which are expected to be biofuels. In this paper I examine what biofuel certificates are, what they can achieve and what their limitations are. Methodologically, I will evaluate them using the standards of instrumental, practical and communicative rationality. With regard to instrumental rationality, I conclude that the EU RED makes an important but unjustified assumption in demanding certified biofuels for its target: that if biofuel production is sustainable, then biofuel use is too. I also argue that, where the EU assumes that biofuel certification is a sufficient means to achieve the EU RED's goals, it is at best an insufficient means and at worst not a means at all towards achieving these goals. With regard to practical rationality, I argue that more attention needs to be paid to trade-offs between different goals in the EU RED, particularly with regard to providing investor security and not capping transport energy consumption. With regard to communicative rationality, I argue that the policy-making process of the EU RED has been seriously flawed, and that certification development processes also can improve significantly.

Publication Title Journal of Agricultural & Environmental Ethics
Volume 28
Issue 4
Pages 667-681
ISBN/ISSN 0893-4282
Language English
Author Address Department of Philosophy and Ethics, IPO 1.09, School of Innovation Sciences, Eindhoven University of Technology, 5600 MB Eindhoven,
Cite this work

Researchers should cite this work as follows:

  1. Biofuels
  2. Certification
  3. Energy
  4. Europe
  5. peer-reviewed
  6. Production
  7. renewable resources
  8. rural development
  9. standards
  10. sustainability
  1. peer-reviewed